Connor Storrie’s Lance may have taken his final bow on Criminal Minds: Evolution in the 17 July 2026 episode on Paramount+, after the fan‑favourite character was seemingly killed off in the penultimate chapter of season 19. The storyline left many viewers asking the same thing in real time on social media: is Connor Storrie actually leaving Criminal Minds: Evolution for good, or is this one of those deaths the show quietly walks back later?
For context, Lance was never meant to be a long‑term fixture in the Criminal Minds: Evolution universe. Introduced this season as a prickly, often unlikeable presence, the character was designed as part of the overarching ‘Fan’ storyline that has driven season 19. That plan shifted when showrunner Erica Messer and the writers found more to mine in his uneasy charm, stretching his run far beyond the original blueprint and widening his emotional connection to the BAU team.
How Connor Storrie’s Lance Exit Played Out On Screen
The news came after the latest episode appeared to close the book on Lance in brutal fashion. Within the hour’s climactic sequence, he is targeted by the Fan, the serial killer who has been stalking anyone caught inside his deadly orbit. Lance is apparently “taken out”, as the recap-friendly phrasing goes, in an attack that is not shown in full detail but is clearly intended to read as fatal.
On a practical level, it makes sense. Storrie, whose star has risen sharply off the back of his work on Heated Rivalry and other projects, was never locked in as a series regular. The Criminal Minds: Evolution team effectively grabbed more time with him than they expected, then chose to fold his character back into the darker endgame of the season rather than let him simply drift away off screen.
Speaking to TV Insider about building that arc, Erica Messer was very plain about their ambitions for Lance and, by extension, for Connor Storrie’s expanded role this year.
‘We really wanted him to just play a bigger part in The Fan’s journey,’ she explained, looking back on how the writers retooled things once they saw what Storrie was doing with the material. She noted that Lance arrives in episode 4, ‘pretty much a jerk’, before Alvez cracks open a different view of him as someone who might not have anyone else in his life.
That shift, tied up in his dynamic with Laura, became the spine of a low‑key redemption narrative. Lance was still sharp‑edged, still a pain, but no longer a one‑note irritant in the plot. For a character who was meant to be relatively disposable, that is a decent upgrade.
Erica Messer Leaves The Door A Tiny Bit Ajar For Connor Storrie
For starters, Messer is not pretending it was an ambiguous exit just for shock value. On the question of whether Lance has actually died, she did not exactly mince words.
‘It certainly seems like Lance gets killed,’ she said. ‘I mean, in some ways, we’re like, “You never say never because we didn’t actually see it.” But yeah, at the end of the day, it felt like everyone in The Fan’s orbit was going to die.’
That is about as honest as showrunner hedging gets. On the one hand, she is clearly positioning Lance as another casualty of the Fan’s bloody campaign. On the other, she knows genre TV fans have long memories and a forensic eye for what is shown versus what is only described. If a death is not on camera, the speculation machine kicks in automatically.
Messer even acknowledged the upside of stretching Lance’s stay to the second‑to‑last episode of the season, saying she was ‘glad that we saw Lance’s character extending into the penultimate’. That is not just a structural note, it is a tacit nod to Storrie’s impact on the series this year. You do not hold a character back that long unless you think they bring something extra when the plot is supposed to be tightening.
So, is Connor Storrie gone from Criminal Minds: Evolution? On any immediate reading of the episode and Messer’s comments, yes. The story has moved to a place where Lance is dead, and the BAU’s focus shifts to whether they can stop the Fan once and for all in the finale. The door that is still technically open is a fraction of an inch and looks more like a safety valve than a concrete plan.
Nothing is confirmed yet about future seasons or surprise returns, so everything should be taken with a grain of salt.
Fans React To Connor Storrie’s Sudden Exit
In case you missed it live, the reaction as the episode aired was fast and pretty mad. Viewers who had grown attached to Lance’s messy humanity, precisely because he started off so obnoxious, were not thrilled to see him taken out so close to the finish line.
Some praised the decision online as a gutsy return to the franchise’s grimmer instincts, arguing that a villain as meticulous as the Fan should leave a serious body count. Others pushed back, complaining that just when Lance was becoming genuinely sympathetic he was written off, which felt to them like punishment for caring.
There is also a practical concern humming underneath the chatter. With Storrie’s schedule filling up away from the procedural world, fans are reading this as the show’s way of letting him go cleanly. In television terms, a definitive death can sometimes be kinder than an open‑ended disappearance that never quite gets resolved because everyone is too busy to come back and tie a bow on it.
What is clear, even from Messer’s carefully couched comments, is that Lance was never a simple placeholder. He shaped the Fan’s story, shifted how Alvez and Laura were written in response to him and added a spiky, unpredictable energy to an ensemble that could easily settle into routine. That is a lot of influence for someone originally planned as short‑term ‘orbit’ around the main threat.
Whether that is enough to tempt the writers to pull off a wild survival reveal somewhere down the line is another question. For now, Criminal Minds: Evolution is treating Connor Storrie’s Lance as gone, and letting the fallout land where it hurts most.
Discover more from CELEBEAT
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
